Showing posts with label law. Show all posts
Showing posts with label law. Show all posts

Saturday, January 29, 2022

Impact of hurried legislation in our society_ M Anas Ebrahim

Since the independence of India, our parliament has been the primary law-making body of our government and as our society progressed at a rapid pace, our lawmakers were able to keep up with it most of the time. However, in recent years, the parliament has been hastily passing bills without sufficient deliberation and the impact of the enforcement of such laws is drastic. 

GENDER JUSTICE_CRESCENT SCHOOL OF LAW_GAYATHRI T

 

GENDER JUSTICE

                            Blink. Blink. Blink. It's the dreaded cursor-on-a-blank-screen experience that all writers — amateur or professional, aspiring or experienced — know and dread. And of all times for it to occur, it seems to plague us the most when trying to write an introduction.

Here’s mine…. What is that that strikes your mind when u come across gender justice? I got brain-stormed spontaneously with a lot of injustice, laws, incidents and stuffs related to gender justice… Let’s all get drenched in this intrigued, never-ending discussion, hoping, to arise remedies and invoke the right sense of gender justice and achieve justice in the near future.

I’ve pushed the bunch of grey matter from my brain through my fingers and keys to your screen now… gender justice is far from the writings and laws, the execution of those, comprises the major cut of concrete gender justice. Gender justice is achieved only when both men and women relish equal opportunities and rights in the civic life.

Our laws of the land have got amended repeatedly in-order to save the interest of equality before the law and also has been trying elevate gender justice by constructing provisions particularly for women. The constitution of India stipulates that, women are equal to men and they are protected to effective participation in the administration of the country. The Articles, article 14(right to equality), article 15(3) (special provision for women), art 16 (equal employment), article 39(a) (adequate means of livelihood to both sexes), article 39(d) (equal pay), article 42 (maternity relief at work), article 51A (renounce practice derogatory to dignity of women), article 234D (3) (4) and 234T (3)(4) (reservation for women in panchayat and municipalities) are denoted in our constitution to buoy-up the status of women in our nation.

In Danial Latifi v. Union of India, the SC held that section 3 and 4 of Muslim women (protection of rights on divorce) act was not violative of article 14.

In Vijay Lakshmi v. Punjab university, the SC held that appointment of lady principal exclusively in a girl’s college is not violative of article 14.

In Vijay Sharma v. UOI, the Bombay HC held that a mother who wants to terminate pregnancy not because of the sex of the foetus but due to other circumstances mentioned in MTP act.

In order to diminish the crime against women, various legislation like the protection of women from the domestic violence act,2005, dowry prohibition act, the maternity relief act, Muslim women protection of rights on divorce act, the indecent representation of women act, the Hindu women right to property act etc. have been made to protect women’s right. Though, our law has intended and efforted to protect women’s right and establish equality of the sexes, the gender justice has not fully ripened. More over the injustice against women is still prevailing in different unrecognised variant forms.

Women are still subjected to shaming due to the prevailing body standard rules. Cheers to my pretty women who is reading this… u are as beautiful as you are, naturally. In the bygone week, I was in a park with one of my friends, I saw a woman who was heartly laughing, it seemed like friends-meeting after many years, the women’s husband warned her to behave “lady-like”. Immediately I grew thinking of- Aren’t women have freedom to express their feelings? Who set the lady-like rule? Who set the body standards? It’s time we break those rules, these rules have pushed women lose natural beauty and artificialize her own self. Isn’t this an intangible unjust to women forbidding her to live life in her own style.



This Photo by Unknown Author is licensed under CC BY-SA



Contribution of mass media in abusing women…Aren’t women objectified and commoditised in the present when it comes to advertisements? My answer is a strong-but-sad yes. All the time, mass media portrays women as beautiful, soft and lovely creature, and so-admired by men. Further-more, are portrayed as defenceless character serving men, taking care of family, nurturing kids etc. A popular soap advertisement exhibits a man surprising for a woman(mom) being splendid. This advertisement shook me, aren’t women beautiful as mothers? Is “you don’t look like a mother at all” even a compliment? These kinds of compliment are minor but ground unjust and strip the dignity of women. Why is that that always break-up songs reveal only men’s feeling? And why Songs that portray women merely as beauty commodity still exist? It’s because the eye of the society sees women solely as beautiful, sweet, ever-serving, inferior to men etc.

In Air India v. Nargesh Meerza, the SC struck down the Air India and Indian Airlines regulations on the age of retirement and pregnancy bar on the services of the airhostesses as unconstitutional as it violates article 14.

Safety not a curtain to curtail women… In our existing society women are free to socialize but always subjected to men, quoting the term “protection”. Sometimes, protection’s nose is found in the business of women’s freedom, sarcastically.

In Vishaka v. State of Rajasthan, the SC laid down the guidelines to prevent sexual harassment of working women.

Double trouble… nowadays working-women is normalised, but it ends up with double responsibility for her to work and also to take care of the household. Sharing of household is likewise to be considered in-order to balance justice for men and women.

 
This Photo by Unknown Author is licensed under CC BY-NC

Laws still need amendments prior to eliminate even the lilliputian issues surrounding the injustice to women. The law protecting a Muslim man to marry three wives is misused nowadays and also no women will prefer her share-spouse, this law could be established as unconstitutional as this law gives superiority to men and also reflects that, women need maintenance and protection from men or-else her existence is doubtful; infringing article 14 and also article 51A.The sec 6 (a) of the Hindu minority and guardianship act, 1956 states that only after the father, the mother is regarded as the natural guardian, here, mother who has equal rights, the one who carried and gave birth is put as a second preference to men. Why isn’t mother have equal privilege as father? Equality is questioned here. Marital rape to be declared as crime. Is marriage a license to marital rape? Why not consent considered? Aren’t women objectified and exploited for male’s sexual enjoyment and for reproducing children by allowing of marital rape. A childless-woman is also entitled to receive the dignity of a women, but the hard truth is that this-women is socially excluded. The shield for childless women could possibly be fortified by law.

This Photo by Unknown Author is licensed under CC BY-NC-ND



This Photo by Unknown Author is licensed under CC BY-NC-ND


Iniquitous position of women in their own house amounting to undersized but significant abuse. Men are always unbothered of Sterilization and contraceptives, and these are considered to be concern of woman alone and are solely subjected to women. Women are always treated either as backup or second choice only posterior to men. To welcome the change-of-view, teaching-cooking, cleaning and period to both; son and daughter is crucial. This will at-least help the subsequent generations to have concrete equality.

Though, our laws protect-women’s well-being by authorizing provisions for divorce and widow remarriage, the acceptance of these provisions is refused by our society. Yes, I agree that changing the mindset of this persistent patriarchal society might take plenty of time but hoping for change and working for it is always half success.

The gloomy truth is that Women are abused in all dimensions; sexually, physically, verbally, economically, psychologically, mentally and what not... even after several measures taken to reduce unfairness. It’s all about the way of thinking and the change in the mindset of people of the society, that could aid in establishing just for women; neither the papers nor the law nor the voice for justice is going to help in hoisting justice. It’s more than a cosmic work to change view of people who are already habitual to this vile patriarchal system but preaching youngsters and kids; not about “treating women equal” but just that there is “inessential difference between men and women”. I hope, this blog would have added a spark to light the colourful cracker of gender justice in future. Fingers crossed🤞…






THE SYMBIOTIC RELATION OF LAW AND SOCIETY: A SOCIO-LEGAL APPROACH_CRESCENT LAW SCHOOL_SUJAN



 INTRODUCTIONThe common view of a layman, that law has no influence on their lives and that it moves at a slow pace, is quite the contrary to a lawman's view, who argues that law is dynamic and changing in order to facilitate the needs of the society towards its progression. And as always the lawman stands corrected. The discussions in editorials and news channel debates about contemporary issues like Farm Bills, Nirbhaya Act, Rights of LGBTQ+ community which have changed our legal juxtaposition, bear witness to their argument. This brings us back to the age old question, why should we study the relation between Law and Society? The answer lies in the symbiotic relationship of Law and Society, whereby one cannot exist without the other. This blog aims at establishing that relationship between the two and help the reader understand that Law is the benchmark of a society's civilization.


THEORETICAL INTERDEPENDENCE OF LAW AND SOCIETY

Before delving into their interdependence, understanding what is a society and what is law is indispensable. August Comte, the father of sociology, viewed society as a social organism possessing a harmony of structure and function. Mac Iver and Page defined, “Society is a system of usages and procedures, authority and mutual aid, of many groupings and divisions, of human behavior and of liberties.” As suggested by the Sociologists, we can construe that society differs from one and other as the likeness of mind and beliefs differs. These beliefs or norms are based on morality, which ultimately qualifies to become a law and the violation of the same attracts sanctions. This raises the question, what is law?

The term 'Law' has many definitions and the development of the legal system has been theorised by many Jurists, which has branched into various schools of thought such as Philosophical, Analytical, Historical, Comparative and Sociological. According to Roscoe Pound, “Law is an authoritative cannon of value laid down by the force of politically organized society” and according to Legal Anthropologist BronisÅ‚aw Malinowski defines, "Law is a body of binding obligations…..kept in force by the specific mechanisms of reciprocity and publicity inherent in the structure of society." The inclusion of the word "society" in these two undisputed definitions clearly suggest that Law is the governing body of a society, made by the society and by society, the author means, the people or organisation of people. This subsequently proves that the lawmakers and law abiders are people, whereby establishing, law of the land affects every person in the society. As always, we've arrived at the next question, what is the law of land and its relevance?


CONSTITUTION : THE SUPREME LAW OF THE LAND


The Constitution is the basic principles and laws of a nation or social group that determines the powers and duties of government and guarantees certain rights to its people. This Law governs us and declares who governs us and thereby called the Supreme Law of the land. As rigid as its definition may sound, the Constitution is not so. It is flexible enough to accommodate the changing demands of society, for it is the law governing the society. The 105 Amendments in our Constitution can testify on this behalf, all of which were made to ease our lives and enhance our rights. So, does that mean the Constitution can change according to the whims and fancies of a particular group? Well, we don't want Anarchy, do we?


The answer lies in two doctrines evolved by our Judiciary i.e. Basic Structure Doctrine and Constitutional Morality Doctrine. The former states that the Constitution cannot be amended inconsistent with the Basic Structure of our Constitution which includes secularism, fundamental rights, parliamentary democracy, etc. The latter states that while interpreting the Constitution, courts must adhere to noble principles enshrined in a Constitution. Three out of five Supreme Court Judges in Navtej Singh Johar & others v. Union of India & others, where the Supreme Court struck down Section 377 of Indian Penal Code to protect the rights of LGBTQ+ Community, held that constitutional morality has an overriding effect on public morality and that the goal of the Court is to transform society or to convert public morality into constitutional morality. This shows that the relationship between society and law is a double edged sword and the question of what controls who and who controls what, is a question the readers can answer by now. Yes, it's a sheer balance between the both and no overpowering each other.


The Part III of our Constitution guarantees six fundamental rights i.e. Right to Equality, Against Exploitation, Freedoms, Freedom of Religion, Cultural and Educational Rights, Constitutional Remedies including Life and Liberty. The Part IV-A of our Constitution enumerates the Fundamental Duties of the citizens. This again substantiates the point that the Law works for the society by enforcing the fundamental rights but we also work for the law by practicing the fundamental duties, an harmonious relationship. The Parliament, constituted by the elected representatives of the society according to Constitutional law, is tasked with serving the society and protecting their rights, by legislating supplementary laws. The Executive wing appointed by the Parliament enforces these supplementary laws. The Judiciary ensures that the rights are not violated and ensures its safe enforcement. This again establishes the stance that law is the tool of the society and society is the tool of the law. How big of a tool is law for society? We'll move to that discussion now.


PEOPLE AND LAW


The practicality of law and how much it influences the people has been highlighted previously. But the usage of law by people especially individuals is a less noted yet a prominent area of discussion. This can be elucidated under two heads i.e. Individual Justice and Collective Justice. The Courts of Law are the primary means of justice for an individual and the society, collectively. An individual whose fundamental or constitutional or statutory right is violated, he has the locus standi to claim his compensation or other means of justification. Civil Suits, Petitions in Tribunals, Civil Writs, Arbitration, Lok Adalats and other dispute resolution methods can be employed by the individual to enforce his right and protect himself from any violation. Similarly, Writ petitions disguised as Public Interest Litigations filed before the High Courts and Supreme Court, are the means of justice for a group of people, thereby ensuring collective justice. Throughout history, we have seen numerous prominent cases and judgments which have expanded the scope of Art 21 and Indian Constitution, struck down various laws and provisions and questioned various authorities, all of which shows how good of a tool is law for the society.


CONCLUSION

As stated in every foregoing paragraph, the author again stresses that the Law and Society are interrelated. The above discussion cited certain examples of the recent Laws and Amendments such as the Criminal Law Amendment Act, 2013 also known as Nirbhaya Act; the decriminalization of Section 377 of Indian Penal Code whereby consensual adult homosexual relationships and decriminalization of Section 497 whereby adultery are no more an offence; the repeal of Farm Bills; the recognition of Third Gender Rights, The Muslim Women (Protection of Rights on Marriage) Act, 2019 or the inclusion of Right to Privacy within Right to Life and Personal Liberty, guaranteed by Article 21 of Constitution of India. All of these are a directly proportional result of changing societal norms and values. Law is the end to conflicts and means to curb offences but at the same time the means to enhance or protect the rights of individuals and society. But it has been the society who makes these laws through various mechanisms. This all culminates at being the evidence of the influence that law and society have on each other, throughout their growth and development. The entire blog post focused on the primary question, what is the relationship between law and society? In pursuit of finding its answer, we stumbled upon many more questions, all of which aided in the final conclusion that Law and Society needs to go hand in hand for the mutual benefit of each other and thereby justifying the title of the blog "The Symbiotic Relation of Law and Society."


Authored by,Sujan Ganesh

image courtesy : pexels website available at https://www.pexels.com/